Milwaukee County Judge Hannah Dugan Faces Federal Trial
Milwaukee County Circuit Judge Hannah Dugan is at the center of a high-profile federal trial following allegations that she helped an undocumented man evade federal immigration authorities inside the Milwaukee County Courthouse in April 2025. The defendant, Eduardo Flores-Ruiz, faced pending state battery charges and was also wanted by ICE. Prosecutors argue that Dugan’s actions — directing federal agents away from hallways and facilitating Flores-Ruiz’s exit — constituted obstruction of a federal proceeding and concealment to prevent arrest, both felony offenses.
On Day 3 of the trial (Dec. 17, 2025), federal prosecutors rested their case after presenting testimony from law enforcement officers, courthouse staff, and fellow judges. Key evidence included testimony from federal agents describing how Dugan’s instructions disrupted the arrest, created confusion, and forced agents to pursue Flores-Ruiz outside the courthouse. Audio recordings were also introduced, including a clip in which Dugan allegedly said, “I’ll get the heat,” a statement prosecutors claim demonstrates her awareness of potential consequences.
Testimony from fellow judges, including Judge Kristela Cervera, highlighted the ethical tensions the incident caused within the courthouse. Colleagues described feeling “mortified” and “shocked” by Dugan’s involvement, with some suggesting her actions were inappropriate and contrary to judicial norms. Chief Judge Carl Ashley and other senior staff also testified about internal procedures for managing federal law enforcement in the courthouse, emphasizing that Dugan’s interventions exceeded standard courtroom authority.
Dugan’s defense team, led by attorney Steven Biskupic, confirmed that she will not testify in her own defense, a strategic choice aimed at avoiding cross-examination risks. The defense plans to call four witnesses, likely focusing on courtroom management, safety protocols, and judicial discretion. The goal is to reframe her actions as lawful judicial oversight rather than criminal intent.
The trial has been closely watched because it involves rare charges against a sitting judge, highlighting the delicate balance between judicial authority and federal law enforcement powers. Critics of the prosecution argue that the case may be politically charged due to federal immigration enforcement policies, while supporters insist no individual — including a judge — should obstruct federal authorities.
Judge Lynn Adelman, overseeing the case, indicated that the trial could move to closing arguments by Thursday, Dec. 18, with jury deliberations to follow soon after. The fast pace suggests the court intends a swift resolution. The outcome will likely set an important precedent regarding how far state-level judges can go in exercising authority when federal law enforcement is involved.
Who is Hannah Dugan and What Happened?
Hannah Dugan is a Milwaukee County Circuit Judge facing federal charges for allegedly helping an undocumented man evade federal immigration authorities inside the courthouse. The defendant, Eduardo Flores-Ruiz, had pending state battery charges and was also wanted by ICE.
The incident occurred in April 2025 when federal agents attempted to take Flores-Ruiz into custody. Dugan is accused of:
-
Directing federal agents away from the hallway where Flores-Ruiz was expected to exit.
-
Facilitating his movement through a private exit.
-
Slowing down or obstructing federal enforcement actions inside the courthouse.
Dugan’s actions are alleged to constitute obstruction of a federal proceeding and concealment to prevent an arrest, both felony charges. If convicted, she could face up to six years in prison.
Legal Context
A. Federal Charges
-
Obstruction of a proceeding (18 U.S.C. §1503): Involves interfering with the orderly administration of justice, including federal investigations or proceedings.
-
Concealment to prevent arrest (18 U.S.C. § 1071 or § 3): Involves knowingly hiding or shielding someone from lawful authorities.
These are serious felonies because they strike at the heart of federal law enforcement authority, particularly when a judge is implicated.
B. Judicial Authority Defense
Dugan’s defense argues that:
-
Judges have broad discretion over courtroom management.
-
She was acting within her authority to direct people and maintain safety.
-
Any delays or redirections were procedural, not intentional obstruction.
This defense is nuanced because federal prosecutors must prove intent, not just the act of redirecting someone.
Day 3 Analysis: Key Takeaways
A. Government Rested Its Case
-
All prosecution witnesses have testified, including law enforcement officers, court staff, and judicial colleagues.
-
Evidence included testimony, audio recordings, and internal courthouse communications.
Significance: Resting the case indicates prosecutors believe they’ve presented sufficient evidence for the jury to find guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
B. Defense Strategy
-
Dugan will not testify, a strategic choice to avoid cross-examination pitfalls.
-
Defense plans to call four witnesses, likely focusing on:
-
Courtroom authority and safety protocols
-
Intent and procedural reasoning
-
Challenging credibility of federal witness testimony
-
Analysis: The defense will attempt to undercut the notion of criminal intent and frame Dugan’s actions as judicial discretion rather than obstruction.
C. Key Evidence Highlights
-
Audio: “I’ll get the heat” — prosecutors argue this shows Dugan understood she risked consequences.
-
Colleague judge testimony — peers expressed shock and ethical concern.
-
Federal agent testimony — agents reported procedural confusion and delays caused by Dugan’s instructions.
Analysis: These pieces of evidence will likely be central in jury deliberations, balancing intent vs. discretion.
D. Trial Status and Timeline
-
Judge Adelman expects closing arguments Thursday afternoon, with jury deliberations shortly afterward.
-
This is a fast-moving federal trial, indicating the court’s priority to resolve the case efficiently.
Implications
A. For Judges and Courtroom Authority
-
If Dugan is convicted, it would set a rare precedent showing that judges can be criminally liable for interfering with federal enforcement.
-
Raises questions about limits of judicial discretion when federal authorities are present.
B. For Federal Immigration Enforcement
-
The case highlights tensions between local and federal jurisdictions.
-
Could influence how courts handle ICE arrests in sensitive contexts in the future.
C. Political and Public Perception
-
The case has received national attention because it involves a sitting judge, immigration enforcement, and high-profile legal proceedings.
-
Media coverage and juror interpretation could impact public trust in both the judiciary and federal law enforcement.
What to Watch Next
-
Defense Witnesses — will they convincingly argue Dugan acted within her authority?
-
Closing Arguments — framing of intent vs. discretion will be critical.
-
Jury Deliberations — how jurors interpret the “I’ll get the heat” audio and colleague testimony.
-
Potential Appeals — regardless of outcome, any conviction will likely be appealed, possibly citing judicial immunity or overreach.
Conclusion
Day 3 of the Dugan trial represents a pivotal moment: the prosecution has presented its full case, and the defense now faces the task of reframing courtroom discretion as lawful action. The trial underscores federal-local tensions, the boundaries of judicial authority, and the intersection of law and politics.

