Two DOJ Lawyers Face AI Misconduct Probes
Two lawyers working for the United States Department of Justice are facing potential disciplinary action following separate investigations into their use of artificial intelligence (AI) in government legal work. The department’s Office of Professional Responsibility found that both attorneys violated professional conduct rules through their handling of AI-generated information and confidential government documents. The findings highlight growing concerns about the risks of using artificial intelligence in legal proceedings, particularly when lawyers fail to verify information or protect sensitive materials. Both cases have been referred to the department’s Professional Misconduct Review Unit, which has the authority to impose disciplinary measures.
The first case involves an assistant United States attorney who submitted a legal document containing fabricated quotations and inaccurate descriptions of court decisions. The document included statements that did not accurately reflect the rulings of previously decided cases. These errors were connected to the attorney’s use of a generative AI platform while preparing the court filing. Although artificial intelligence can assist lawyers with research and drafting, the incident demonstrated how AI-generated content can introduce false information into official legal documents when it is not properly reviewed and verified before submission.
The situation became more serious when the court questioned the attorney about the inaccuracies found in the filing. Instead of immediately acknowledging that artificial intelligence had contributed to the errors, the attorney initially explained that the problems occurred because an unfinished draft had accidentally been submitted. This explanation failed to disclose the actual role of AI in preparing the document. The attorney’s response raised additional concerns because the issue was no longer limited to inaccurate legal information but also involved the responsibility to provide honest and complete answers to the court.
During a subsequent hearing, the attorney made further statements about his use of generative AI that were determined to be false or misleading. The department’s ethics investigation concluded that the attorney knowingly and intentionally violated professional conduct obligations and the general duty of candor owed to the court. Lawyers are expected to communicate honestly with judges, disclose relevant information when required, and take responsibility for the accuracy of documents submitted under their names. Attempting to conceal the source of errors can create a separate and potentially more serious professional violation.
The Office of Professional Responsibility determined that the attorney’s actions violated professional standards in two important ways. First, he failed to honestly explain that AI assistance had contributed to fabricated quotations and misrepresented legal decisions in the original filing. Second, he made false or misleading statements during the court hearing when questioned about the use of the technology. The findings were referred to the Professional Misconduct Review Unit for further consideration and possible disciplinary action. The referral means the matter has advanced to the department’s disciplinary review process, although it does not automatically establish what final punishment will be imposed.
The second investigation involved another Justice Department attorney who used a publicly available artificial intelligence platform to assist with government work. The attorney uploaded official documents to the platform despite restrictions governing how the information could be shared. Some of the materials were covered by a tribunal’s protective order, which limited access to confidential information and prohibited unauthorized disclosure. The investigation found that the attorney had uploaded multiple documents, including materials that contained sensitive government information and personal details belonging to department employees.
The documents reportedly included personally identifiable information, including medical information. This raised serious concerns about confidentiality, privacy, and the handling of protected government records. Public AI platforms may process information submitted by users under their own data-handling practices, which can create risks when confidential or restricted materials are uploaded without proper authorization. Government attorneys are expected to understand these risks and follow established safeguards when using outside technology for official responsibilities.
The department’s ethics office concluded that the second attorney recklessly violated professional conduct rules by using the public AI platform in violation of department policy. It also determined that the attorney knowingly and intentionally violated professional obligations by uploading confidential department documents. Furthermore, the attorney knowingly violated professional conduct rules and the tribunal’s protective order by submitting documents that he knew were subject to those restrictions. These findings show that the investigation involved more than a general failure to follow internal procedures. It also concerned the unauthorized handling of protected information and noncompliance with a formal court-related order.
Both investigations were published in separate summaries that did not identify the attorneys involved, their specific workplaces, or whether they remained employed by the department. The artificial intelligence platforms used in the incidents were also not publicly identified. The department confirmed that the findings had been referred to its Professional Misconduct Review Unit, which is responsible for reviewing misconduct matters and determining appropriate disciplinary measures. It was also unclear whether the findings had been referred to state bar authorities, which independently oversee professional conduct and licensing requirements for attorneys.
The Justice Department stated that it takes its responsibility to investigate and address allegations of professional misconduct seriously and handles these matters through established procedures. The cases demonstrate that government lawyers are not exempt from professional accountability when using emerging technologies. Even when AI tools are introduced to improve efficiency, attorneys remain responsible for checking legal authorities, verifying quotations, protecting confidential information, and ensuring that their work complies with court orders and professional obligations. The use of technology does not transfer legal responsibility from the attorney to the software provider.
The incidents also reflect a broader challenge facing the legal profession as generative AI becomes increasingly common in legal research, document preparation, and other professional tasks. Artificial intelligence can produce convincing but inaccurate legal information, including fabricated quotations and incorrect interpretations of actual court decisions. At the same time, uploading sensitive records to public platforms can expose confidential information to unauthorized access or processing. These risks make independent verification, proper data protection, and transparency essential whenever lawyers use AI-assisted tools. The investigations serve as a warning that convenience and efficiency cannot take priority over professional ethics, confidentiality, and the duty to uphold the integrity of the judicial system.
KEY LEGAL OUTCOME
-
The Justice Department found that two government attorneys violated professional conduct rules through separate incidents involving artificial intelligence.
-
The first attorney knowingly misled a court about AI-generated errors, including fabricated quotations and misrepresented case holdings.
-
The second attorney violated confidentiality requirements by uploading protected government documents and sensitive employee information to a public AI platform.
-
Both investigations were referred to the department’s Professional Misconduct Review Unit for possible disciplinary action.
-
The findings reinforce that attorneys remain personally responsible for accuracy, honesty, confidentiality, and compliance with court orders when using AI tools.
WHY IT MATTERS
-
Legal accountability: Lawyers cannot avoid professional responsibility by blaming artificial intelligence for inaccurate court filings or misleading legal arguments.
-
Client confidentiality: Uploading sensitive documents to public AI platforms can expose protected information and create serious privacy concerns.
-
Judicial integrity: Fabricated quotations and inaccurate legal citations can undermine judges’ confidence in court submissions and the fairness of legal proceedings.
-
AI regulation: The cases highlight the need for stronger safeguards, clear policies, and responsible AI practices within government agencies and law firms.
-
Professional ethics: The investigations establish an important reminder that technological convenience must never replace honesty, independent verification, and compliance with professional standards.

