AntitrustConsumer Protection

Google Settlement Lawyers Slash $85M Fee Bid

Lawyers representing consumers in an antitrust case against Google have reduced their request for legal fees from $85 million to $78.6 million after a federal judge sharply criticized their original demand. The attorneys helped negotiate a $630 million settlement involving Google’s Play Store, but U.S. District Judge James Donato of the Northern District of California questioned whether their work justified such a substantial payment. The revised request represents another attempt by the legal team to secure compensation after the court raised concerns about inadequate billing records and the extent of the lawyers’ contributions to the settlement.

The dispute is part of litigation involving allegations that Google used anticompetitive practices in operating its Play Store for Android devices. The lawsuit accused the company of restricting competition in app distribution and imposing excessive fees on developers and consumers for transactions involving applications and in-app purchases. Plaintiffs argued that Google’s practices limited alternative ways for Android users to obtain applications and make payments, allowing the company to maintain control over important parts of the mobile app marketplace. Google has denied wrongdoing and agreed to resolve the broader litigation through a settlement.

Under the agreement, Google committed $630 million to a fund for eligible consumers and another $70 million to a separate fund administered by the states, bringing the overall settlement to $700 million. The consumer fund is intended to compensate people who made qualifying purchases through Google Play during the relevant period. The settlement also includes changes intended to make it easier for developers to inform users about alternative payment methods and for consumers to download applications outside the Play Store. The agreement was negotiated alongside efforts by state attorneys general and other parties involved in related antitrust litigation.

The lawyers seeking the fees are from Bartlit Beck and Kaplan Fox & Kilsheimer. The consumer plaintiffs’ legal team includes Karma Giulianelli of Bartlit Beck and Hae Sung Nam of Kaplan Fox & Kilsheimer. Their original request sought $85 million, equivalent to approximately 13.5% of the $630 million consumer settlement fund. The attorneys argued that they devoted nearly 100,000 hours to the litigation over more than three years and played an important role in securing the financial and other benefits obtained through the agreement.

Judge Donato, however, questioned whether the requested amount was reasonable in light of the actual results achieved by the consumer lawyers. In an earlier review, he criticized the billing records submitted in support of the request, finding that they did not provide sufficient detail about the work performed or explain the purpose of many recorded activities. The judge said the documentation was inadequate for a fair assessment of the fees and questioned whether the attorneys had demonstrated that their contribution justified such a large share of the settlement.

The judge also examined how much credit the private consumer lawyers deserved for the overall agreement. The settlement was not achieved through their efforts alone. Attorneys representing all 50 U.S. states, the District of Columbia, Puerto Rico, and the U.S. Virgin Islands were involved in the broader negotiations and enforcement efforts. Judge Donato questioned whether the consumer lawyers were seeking compensation for work that primarily benefited other parties or contributed to results achieved through separate litigation. In particular, he pointed to the role of lawyers representing Epic Games, whose separate antitrust case against Google produced significant legal developments concerning the company’s app marketplace practices.

Join YouTube banner

The distinction between the consumer lawyers’ work and the contributions of government attorneys became a central issue in evaluating the fee request. Although the state attorneys general did not plan to object to the original request, the judge was not persuaded that the absence of an objection automatically established that the requested payment was fair to consumers. The settlement fund was intended to benefit people who purchased applications and other digital products through Google Play. As a result, the court emphasized that it had a responsibility to examine whether the requested legal fees would improperly reduce the amount available to eligible consumers.

Following the judge’s criticism, the attorneys submitted a revised request seeking $78.6 million, a reduction of $6.4 million from their original demand. The revised amount still represents a substantial portion of the consumer settlement fund. The lawyers continue to maintain that their work was important to the outcome and that their efforts helped secure meaningful benefits for consumers. Their revised filing is intended to address the court’s concerns and persuade the judge that the requested compensation is justified by the time, resources, and work devoted to the case.

The reduction does not mean that the judge has accepted the new figure or that the lawyers are guaranteed to receive the requested payment. The court must still evaluate whether the revised submission provides sufficient information to support the amount. The judge’s earlier criticism indicates that the review will involve more than simply comparing the new request with the original figure. The attorneys must demonstrate what work they performed, how that work contributed to the settlement, and why the proposed compensation is reasonable in relation to the results obtained for consumers.

The case also highlights the broader legal questions surrounding attorney compensation in large class-action settlements. Lawyers who represent groups of consumers may seek payment from a common settlement fund, but courts have a responsibility to ensure that legal fees do not disproportionately reduce the recovery available to the people represented. Detailed billing records, evidence of the work performed, and a clear explanation of the lawyers’ contribution are important when judges assess these requests. A substantial settlement does not automatically justify a substantial attorney-fee award, particularly when several groups of lawyers and government agencies contributed to the outcome.

For Google Play users, the dispute concerns how much of the consumer settlement fund will ultimately be allocated to the attorneys rather than remaining available for compensation. The $630 million consumer fund and the separate $70 million state fund remain part of the broader $700 million agreement, but the fee dispute could affect the amount distributed to eligible consumers from the consumer portion. The proceedings also demonstrate that courts can closely scrutinize legal fees even after parties have negotiated a major settlement. The revised $78.6 million request now places the focus on whether the attorneys can adequately justify their compensation and show that the amount is fair to the consumers whose interests they represented.

Key Legal Outcome

  • Consumer attorneys reduced their requested legal fees from $85 million to $78.6 million following criticism from U.S. District Judge James Donato.
  • The original request represented approximately 13.5% of the $630 million consumer settlement fund.
  • Judge Donato criticized the lawyers’ billing records for lacking sufficient detail about the work performed and its purpose.
  • The judge questioned how much credit the consumer lawyers deserved for the settlement, given the contributions of state attorneys general and lawyers involved in related litigation.
  • The revised fee request remains subject to judicial review; the court has not yet approved the $78.6 million payment.

Why It Matters

  • Attorney fees in class-action settlements can substantially affect how much money remains available for consumers.
  • Judges have an independent responsibility to determine whether legal-fee requests are reasonable, even when other parties do not object.
  • Lawyers seeking compensation from settlement funds must provide detailed records demonstrating the work performed and the value of their contributions.
  • The case highlights the complexity of assigning credit when private attorneys, government lawyers, and separate litigants contribute to a broader legal resolution.
  • The dispute may influence how attorneys document their work and justify fee requests in future large-scale consumer antitrust settlements.

 

 

 

 

 

 

author avatar
Janice Thompson
Janice Thompson enjoys writing about business, constitutional legal matters and the rule of law.

Janice Thompson

Janice Thompson enjoys writing about business, constitutional legal matters and the rule of law.