Social MediaTechnology

Italy Fines Meta $887 Million Over Photos

Italy’s data protection authority has fined Meta Platforms Ireland €805 million ($887 million) after finding that Facebook accessed photographs, videos, and related metadata stored on Android users’ smartphones without obtaining specific, informed consent. The decision concerns a Facebook feature that suggests images from a user’s phone gallery while browsing the social media platform. Regulators concluded that users were not adequately informed about the feature or given a sufficiently clear choice before their personal media could be accessed. Meta has rejected the regulator’s findings and announced that it intends to appeal.

The penalty, announced on November 14, 2026, is one of the largest fines imposed by an Italian authority against a major technology company. The investigation focused on Meta Platforms Ireland Limited, the entity responsible for the Facebook service in the case. According to Italy’s Data Protection Authority, the company’s Android application accessed users’ private photo galleries through a feature called “Get camera roll suggestions when you’re browsing Facebook.” The feature has been available since 2023 and was designed to recommend photographs and videos from a user’s device as potential content to share on Facebook.

The regulator found that the feature could access a user’s gallery through a single permission request covering multiple functions within the Facebook application. This authorization was not limited to the photo-suggestion feature. Instead, it applied across the app, even though the different functions involved had separate purposes. The authority concluded that this arrangement made it difficult for users to understand precisely what they were authorizing when granting access to their device’s photos and videos.

Another concern involved the wording of the notification presented to users. Investigators found that Facebook used a generic notice asking users to enable additional features without clearly explaining that granting permission would also allow the application to access their photo galleries for content suggestions. As a result, users could approve the permission without fully understanding its implications. The authority also determined that the gallery-suggestion feature was activated by default, further weakening users’ ability to make an informed decision about whether they wanted the functionality.

Join YouTube banner

The investigation began in July 2025 following a complaint from the Bolzano Consumer Protection Centre. Italian regulators conducted a technical assessment of the Facebook application and examined how the feature operated on Android devices. Their findings indicated that the permission could allow the application to read the device’s entire photo archive, generally on an ongoing basis. The authority also raised concerns that neither users nor regulators could adequately determine which information was actually being accessed and used through the feature. Approximately 20 million Android users in Italy were identified as potentially affected by the practice.

The Italian Data Protection Authority determined that Meta’s practices violated Article 122 of Italy’s Data Protection Code, which implements protections under the European ePrivacy framework. The provision safeguards information stored on users’ devices as part of their private sphere and requires free and informed consent before applications access that information. Under this framework, the obligation to obtain valid consent applies even when the information is not necessarily transmitted to another party or when a user has not demonstrated a specific financial or other form of harm. The regulator also rejected Meta’s argument that the matter should fall under the jurisdiction of Ireland’s data protection authority, explaining that the ePrivacy rules involved do not provide for the European Union’s one-stop-shop mechanism in this situation.

In addition to the financial penalty, the authority ordered Meta to change how the gallery-suggestion feature operates. Within 60 days, the company must present users with a separate and specific consent request explaining that the feature requires access to their photo galleries. It must also clearly describe the feature’s purpose and explain how users can disable it. The function must remain turned off by default, including for users who had previously granted the broader Android permission. If Meta fails to implement the required changes within the deadline, the feature cannot be activated for users who have not provided valid consent.

The regulator also established reporting requirements to monitor the company’s compliance. Meta must notify the authority within 30 days about the initiatives it has begun to address the violations and provide information on the measures it has implemented within 90 days. These requirements are intended to ensure that the company does more than simply change the wording of its permission requests. The authority expects the feature’s default settings and consent procedures to reflect the specific privacy protections required under Italian law.

In determining the amount of the fine, regulators considered several factors, including the number of people potentially affected and the duration of the infringement. The authority estimated that approximately 20 million Android users in Italy were involved. It also considered that the violation remained ongoing for users who had not updated their Facebook applications and for some who had already granted the broader permission. Other factors included a previous regulatory decision involving Meta in 2019 and what the authority described as the company’s limited cooperation during the investigation. Changes introduced by Meta following the complaint were considered mitigating circumstances, but regulators regarded those adjustments as late and insufficient because they applied only to users who updated their applications. The €805 million penalty represents approximately 0.47% of Meta’s global turnover.

Meta strongly disagreed with the decision and described the fine as disproportionate. A company spokesperson said the feature was intended to help people share photographs and videos on Facebook. Meta argued that users must grant permission through their Android devices before the feature can operate and that they can change those permissions at any time through their settings. The company nevertheless faces the regulator’s conclusion that the general device authorization and the information provided to users did not amount to sufficiently specific and informed consent for the gallery-suggestion function. Meta has said it plans to challenge the decision through an appeal.

The proceedings also raised questions about the distinction between accessing personal media for Facebook features and using that material to develop artificial intelligence systems. However, the Italian authority specifically stated that its investigation did not examine whether Meta used users’ photographs or videos to train AI models. Meta has denied using the content for that purpose. The regulator said it reserved the right to examine separately another feature introduced in 2026 that allows content from users’ photo galleries to be processed through cloud services. That separate issue was not resolved by the November penalty and should not be confused with the findings in the current case.

The decision underscores the growing importance of meaningful consent and transparency in the way technology companies access information stored on personal devices. Regulators are making clear that a broad permission covering an entire application may not satisfy privacy requirements when users are not adequately informed about individual functions and their specific purposes. For Meta, the consequences extend beyond the financial penalty: the company must redesign how it requests access to users’ galleries and ensure that the feature remains disabled until valid consent is obtained. The case could also serve as a warning to other digital platforms that convenience-oriented features do not remove their responsibility to protect users’ private information and comply with European privacy rules.

Key Legal Outcome

  • Italy’s Data Protection Authority fined Meta Platforms Ireland €805 million ($887 million) for accessing Android users’ photographs, videos, and related metadata without obtaining specific, informed consent.
  • Regulators found that Facebook’s gallery-suggestion feature relied on a broad application permission and a generic notice that did not adequately explain the access being authorized.
  • The authority determined that the practice violated Article 122 of Italy’s Data Protection Code, which implements protections under the European ePrivacy framework.
  • Meta must disable the feature by default and obtain separate, specific consent from users within 60 days, including from those who previously granted the broader permission.
  • The authority ordered Meta to report its initial compliance initiatives within 30 days and the measures adopted within 90 days; Meta has announced plans to appeal.

Why It Matters

  • The decision reinforces that permission to access a smartphone’s contents must be based on clear and informed consent, not merely a broad authorization covering multiple app functions.
  • Approximately 20 million Android users in Italy were potentially affected, demonstrating the scale of privacy concerns involving widely used digital platforms.
  • The ruling highlights that activating a feature by default can undermine meaningful user choice when the purpose and scope of data access are not clearly explained.
  • Technology companies may face substantial financial penalties and operational changes when their consent mechanisms fail to meet European privacy requirements.
  • The case raises broader questions about transparency and user control over personal photographs, videos, and other information stored on mobile devices.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

author avatar
Janice Thompson
Janice Thompson enjoys writing about business, constitutional legal matters and the rule of law.

Janice Thompson

Janice Thompson enjoys writing about business, constitutional legal matters and the rule of law.