Federal judge bars Kari Lake from ousting Voice of America’s director
On August 28, 2025, a federal judge in Washington, D.C., blocked Kari Lake—an ally of former President Trump—from removing Michael Abramowitz as director of Voice of America (VOA). The ruling centers on the requirement that only a Senate-confirmed oversight board, not a senior White House adviser, has the legal authority to remove the head of VOA. However, this advisory board had been dissolved earlier in the year, leading to a legal gray zone. Judge Royce Lamberth, appointed by President Reagan, concluded that Abramowitz must be reinstated and that proper removal can only occur after both restoring the board and a majority vote of its members.
Lake, who holds the title of senior adviser at the U.S. Agency for Global Media (USAGM), which oversees VOA, had taken sweeping actions since her appointment. Early this year, she placed VOA’s entire workforce on administrative leave and redirected funding from other US-backed broadcasters—moves carried out under Trump’s executive order to slash the agency to a “minimum presence.” These aggressive steps sparked lawsuits by Abramowitz and surviving staff, arguing Lake overstepped her legal authority. Lamberth’s ruling follows a preliminary injunction granted in April that required the VOA to return to functioning.
In his ruling, Judge Lamberth underscored that if Lake encounters a barrier in removing Abramowitz due to the advisory board’s lack of quorum, the law provides a remedy: replace the board members. His decision not only blocks Lake’s actions but preserves the independence intended by the VOA’s statutory protections. He also signaled that Lake’s actions—but without directly holding her in contempt—were perilously close to contempt of court, and ordered her to testify under oath by mid-September.
This legal confrontation is part of a broader dispute over the independence of U.S. global media institutions. Starting with Trump’s executive order in March, known as the “Voice of Radical America” directive, VOA has faced attempts at restructuring, layoffs, and contract terminations. Lake pushed to downsize USAGM and even proposed pairing VOA with right-leaning media like One America News. VOA’s staff and legal advocates countered with lawsuits claiming domestically funded soft-power journalism was being undermined. Lamberth’s latest ruling marks a significant legal check against politically motivated restructuring, reaffirming the agency’s time-tested firewall against partisan interference.
Lake has publicly criticized the ruling, asserting that presidential control should extend to executive oversight of agencies like VOA and insisting that the court’s decision disregards electoral consequences. In contrast, Abramowitz and VOA staff welcomed the ruling as a vindication of statutory protection and press independence, pointing to the need to resume robust international programming uninterrupted by political meddling. The ruling likely propels this conflict toward appeal, setting the stage for a higher-stakes constitutional confrontation over the Separation of Powers and agency autonomy.

Why It Matters
-
Preserves institutional independence: Reinforces legal protections that shield VOA from political control.
-
Upholds checks and balances: Affirms that executive authority does not override statutory regulatory mechanisms.
-
Protects press freedom: Prevents politicized interference with government-funded international broadcasters.
-
Sets constitutional precedent: Clarifies limits on executive power, especially when oversight bodies are dismantled.
-
Ensures continuity of international messaging: Safeguards VOA’s mission of providing independent news to global audiences.
Key Legal Outcomes
-
Abramowitz reinstated: The VOA director remains in place until proper removal procedures are followed.
-
Permanent injunction issued: Lake is barred from removing Abramowitz without restoring the oversight board.
-
Statute upheld: The law governing appointment and removal of VOA leaders was deemed constitutional.
-
Potential contempt flagged: Lake must testify — her actions are close to contempt, per the judge.
-
Legal pathway clarified: Should the board lack quorum, the president must repopulate it to remove a director.
- Publication Date: August 28, 2025
- Live Link: Read the CNN Business article here
