US News

Prosecutors Sue Newsom Over Death Row Plan

California Governor Gavin Newsom is facing a legal challenge from prosecutors and families of murder victims over his plan to commute every death sentence in the state to life imprisonment without the possibility of parole. The lawsuit asks the California Supreme Court to block the proposed action, arguing that the governor failed to follow required legal procedures and ignored the rights of victims and their families. The petition was filed by the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation on behalf of district attorneys from 30 California counties, victims’ relatives and other advocacy groups. The plaintiffs argue that Newsom cannot use his executive clemency authority to change hundreds of death sentences without following the safeguards established under state law.

Newsom announced his plan on November 5, 2026, saying he intended to commute the sentences of all 548 people currently on California’s death row. The group includes 529 men and 19 women. If the plan is approved, those prisoners would no longer face execution and would instead serve life sentences without the possibility of parole. This means they would remain imprisoned for the rest of their lives and would not become eligible for release through ordinary parole proceedings. The proposal would represent one of the largest mass commutations of death sentences in American history and would significantly change the status of California’s death row population.

The lawsuit argues that Newsom failed to provide proper notice to district attorneys and victims’ families before announcing the decision. Under California law, prosecutors and victims or their representatives generally receive notification when a governor considers certain requests to reduce a prison sentence. The plaintiffs say these requirements exist so prosecutors can provide relevant information and victims’ families can express their views before a sentence is changed. They argue that the governor’s decision affected hundreds of cases without giving the people directly connected to those cases an opportunity to participate. Some families reportedly learned about the proposed commutations through public announcements rather than direct communication from the state.

A major issue in the case is Newsom’s position that the notification requirements do not apply to his plan. The governor has argued that the relevant procedures are designed for individual commutation applications submitted by prisoners, not for clemency initiated independently by the governor. Because he is exercising his own authority rather than responding to applications, Newsom maintains that he is not required to follow the same notification process before announcing the proposed commutations. He has said his office intends to notify district attorneys after submitting the proposed actions to the California Supreme Court and will ask prosecutors to help contact victims’ families.

Join YouTube banner

The plaintiffs strongly dispute that interpretation. They argue that the governor cannot avoid statutory protections simply by initiating the commutations himself instead of waiting for individual applications. Their petition maintains that victims’ rights and prosecutorial notification requirements should remain applicable regardless of who begins the clemency process. They also argue that the governor should have conducted meaningful individual reviews instead of making a blanket decision covering everyone on death row. According to the lawsuit, each prisoner’s circumstances, criminal history and eligibility should have been examined before the governor announced that every death sentence would be reduced.

The lawsuit also raises questions about the limits of executive clemency under the California Constitution. Although the governor has authority to grant pardons and commutations, that power is subject to certain constitutional requirements. One important restriction involves prisoners convicted of multiple felonies. Under the state constitution, the governor must obtain a recommendation from at least four California Supreme Court justices before granting clemency to individuals with multiple felony convictions. The plaintiffs argue that this requirement prevents the governor from independently changing certain sentences without the court’s involvement. They contend that Newsom’s broad announcement risks undermining the judiciary’s constitutionally assigned role.

Of the 548 prisoners included in the proposed plan, 382 have multiple felony convictions and therefore require review by the California Supreme Court. Newsom has submitted a request seeking the court’s approval for those cases. The plaintiffs argue that the court must independently consider the relevant legal requirements rather than simply approve a decision that has already been announced by the governor. They also claim that the administration did not adequately investigate every prisoner’s criminal history before preparing the list. The lawsuit identifies concerns about possible errors in the records used to determine which prisoners fall under the different constitutional requirements.

The Criminal Justice Legal Foundation, which is representing the plaintiffs, argues that the governor’s decision amounts to an abuse of executive power. The organization says the clemency process must comply with legal safeguards and cannot be used to bypass the rights of victims or the authority of the courts. Anne Marie Schubert, the foundation’s president and a former district attorney, said the governor should not allow his personal opposition to capital punishment to override sentences imposed through the judicial process. The plaintiffs maintain that judges and juries reached their decisions under existing law and that the governor must respect the procedures governing changes to those sentences.

Newsom has defended his position by pointing to his constitutional authority and long-standing opposition to capital punishment. In 2019, he imposed a moratorium on executions in California, effectively stopping executions during his administration even though death sentences remained in place. He has argued that the death penalty is incompatible with the state’s values and that the criminal justice system cannot guarantee that innocent people will never be executed. His administration has also maintained that the proposed commutations would not release prisoners or erase their convictions. Instead, those affected would remain incarcerated for life without the possibility of parole.

The proposal has divided prosecutors and victims’ families. While the 30 district attorneys involved in the lawsuit oppose the plan, prosecutors from some other California counties have publicly supported it. Some victims’ relatives have also backed the proposed commutations, arguing that life imprisonment without parole is an appropriate alternative to execution and that the death penalty system is costly and carries the risk of irreversible mistakes. Other families oppose the change, saying the death sentences were imposed after years of legal proceedings and that the governor’s decision disregards their experiences and the judgments reached by courts and juries. The disagreement demonstrates that victims’ families do not share a single position on the death penalty or the proposed commutations.

The California Supreme Court will now have to consider the legal arguments presented by the plaintiffs and determine whether the governor’s plan can proceed. The lawsuit seeks to prevent Newsom and state corrections officials from carrying out the proposed commutations without complying with the required procedures. The court has not yet issued a final decision on the challenge. If the plaintiffs succeed, the governor could be required to follow additional notification and review procedures before changing the sentences. If Newsom’s position is upheld, the administration could move forward under its interpretation of the governor’s independent clemency authority, subject to the separate constitutional review required for prisoners with multiple felony convictions. The case could establish important limits on how California governors exercise clemency power in large-scale cases.

Key Legal Outcome

  1. District attorneys from 30 California counties and relatives of murder victims filed a lawsuit asking the California Supreme Court to block Newsom’s proposed commutations.

  2. The plaintiffs argue that Newsom failed to provide legally required notice to prosecutors and victims’ families before announcing the plan.

  3. The lawsuit challenges whether the governor can commute hundreds of death sentences without conducting individual reviews.

  4. The California Constitution requires Supreme Court approval for commutations involving prisoners convicted of multiple felonies; 382 prisoners fall into this category.

  5. The court has not issued a final ruling, and the proposed commutations remain subject to legal and constitutional review.

Why It Matters

  1. Victims’ rights: The lawsuit could clarify whether victims and their families must be notified and given an opportunity to be heard before large-scale commutations.

  2. Executive authority: The case examines the limits of a governor’s power to change criminal sentences through blanket clemency actions.

  3. Judicial oversight: The dispute highlights the California Supreme Court’s constitutional role in reviewing certain commutations.

  4. Death penalty policy: The outcome could affect the future of California’s death row and the state’s approach to capital punishment.

  5. Legal precedent: The ruling could establish how notification, individual review and constitutional safeguards apply to future mass clemency decisions.

Related:

Newsom Seeks to Convert All California Death Sentences to Life

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

author avatar
Janice Thompson
Janice Thompson enjoys writing about business, constitutional legal matters and the rule of law.

Janice Thompson

Janice Thompson enjoys writing about business, constitutional legal matters and the rule of law.